Security Keys Explained: The Simplest Way to Stop Account Hacks

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, Securely Sorted may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Quick answer

Most account hacks start with a fake login page that tricks you into typing your password and a text-message code. A security key is a small device, about the size of a house key, that makes that trick useless. It’s one of the strongest protections available, and it costs less than a dinner out.

A hand holding a key ring with a house key and a small USB security key.
About the size of a house key, so it lives on your key ring. (Stock photo: Pexels.)

What a security key does

When you log in to a supported account, you plug in the key (or tap it on your phone) instead of typing a code. The key checks that it’s talking to the real website before it answers. A fake site can’t get a response, so even if you fall for a convincing phishing page, the attacker gets nothing.

Security keys use an open standard called FIDO2. They also work as passkeys, the newer password-free way to sign in.

Diagram: on the real website, the security key answers and you're signed in. On a fake look-alike site with a slightly different address, the key gives no response and the attacker gets nothing. Text-message codes can be phished; a security key can't be.
The key checks the website before it answers, so a fake site gets nothing.

Who should get one

  • Anyone whose email or social accounts would be a big problem to lose
  • Small business owners, especially for email, banking, and admin accounts
  • Creators with valuable YouTube, Instagram, or TikTok accounts (a common hacking target)
  • People who’ve been hacked before or receive a lot of phishing attempts

Where they work

Major services support security keys, including Google, Microsoft, Apple accounts, Facebook, X, Dropbox, and many password managers and banks.

Which one to buy

Key Best for Where to buy
YubiKey 5C NFC Newer laptops and phones with USB-C; tap-to-use on phones Check price on Amazon
YubiKey 5 NFC Older computers with USB-A ports Check price on Amazon
Yubico Security Key series Budget option for everyday accounts (fewer advanced features) Check price on Amazon
Google Titan Security Key People mostly in the Google ecosystem Check price on Amazon

Always buy two

Register a main key and a backup key on every account, and keep the backup somewhere safe at home. If you lose one, you’re not locked out. If you’re buying your first key, it’s easiest to get both at once. Check price on Amazon. Also save each account’s backup codes in your password manager.

How to set one up (5 minutes per account)

  1. Go to the account’s security settings (look for “2-Step Verification,” “Security keys,” or “Passkeys”).
  2. Choose Add security key.
  3. Insert or tap the key when asked, and touch its button.
  4. Repeat with your backup key.
  5. Start with your main email, then banking, then social media.

Setting one up on a single account takes about five minutes once you’re in the right settings menu. The honest time cost is doing it for every account that matters, so pace yourself: start with email, since that’s usually the account a hacker can use to reset everything else.

Common questions

What if I lose my security key? That’s why you register two. Sign in with your backup key, remove the lost key from your accounts, and register a replacement. Keep each account’s backup codes in your password manager as a last resort.

Does a YubiKey work with iPhone? Yes. NFC models like the YubiKey 5 NFC and 5C NFC work by tapping them to the top of an iPhone. USB-C keys can also plug straight into iPhones with a USB-C port (iPhone 15 and newer).

Can I use one key for every account? Yes. One key can be registered with as many accounts as support security keys. If you save passkeys on the key itself, there’s a limit to how many it can hold, which varies by model.

Do I really need two keys? Yes. A second key is your way back in if one is lost or broken. Apple actually requires at least two security keys before you can use them with an Apple Account, and allows up to six.

Bottom line

Text-message codes are better than nothing, but they can be phished. A security key can’t be. For the price of two keys, you can make your most important accounts dramatically harder to steal. New to two-factor authentication in general? Start with our beginner’s guide. Ready to use one? See setting one up on Gmail, protecting a YouTube channel, or which model works best with an iPhone.

Mcarthur, founder of Securely Sorted

Mcarthur, Founder of Securely SortedI’ve spent 5+ years in hands-on technical support, and now I’m writing the guides I wished existed.

Scroll to Top